top of page
< Back

Amara Cay Resort

TG-0019

Islamorada

United States

Amara Cay Resort — Islamorada, Florida Keys Summary A boutique, coastal‑chic oceanfront resort in Islamorada with hammocks, a private beach, a waterfront pool, and access to all sister‑property amenities across the Islamorada Resort Collection. Ideal for relaxed luxury, boating, water activities, and laid‑back Keys style Location • 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036 • Oceanfront, with views of Alligator Reef Lighthouse Nearest Airport • Miami International Airport (MIA) — ~1 hr 45 min • Key West International Airport (EYW) — ~1 hr 45 min Boutique, modern, coastal‑chic design: • Private beach with hammocks • Oceanfront pool + poolside bar • Access to 3 sister resorts, 12 restaurants, 55+ boat slips, and shared amenities Amenities (Dense List) On‑Site • Oceanfront pool • Private beach w/ hammocks • Tiki Bar • Fitness center • Complimentary activities (yoga, local-style fishing, water shuttles between sister resorts) Sister‑Property Access • Restaurants, pools, beaches, events, and marina access across the Islamorada Resort Collection Guest Services • Free shuttle within 3.7 miles • Complimentary guest laundry • Meeting/event spaces Room Types Standard Rooms & Suites • Private balconies or lanais • Ocean, pool, or garden views • Coastal‑chic décor • Flat‑screen TV, desk, safe Features Guests Highlight • “Brand‑new feel,” modern lobby, beautiful outdoor areas • Oceanfront rooms highly praised Guest Experience Snapshot • Tripadvisor rating: 4.2/5 (2,225 reviews) • Loved for: • Relaxed luxury • Friendly staff • Beautiful pool + beach • Water shuttle between properties • Clean, modern design • Noted trade‑offs: • Paid private parking Nearby Activities • History of Diving Museum (3 miles) • Anne’s Beach (8‑minute drive) • Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park (8‑minute drive) Perfect For • Couples seeking relaxed luxury • Families wanting beach + pool + activities • Guests who want multiple resort experiences in one stay • Boaters (55+ slips across sister properties)

Availability
The schedule for availability is subject to change based on various factors, ensuring flexibility to accommodate different needs and circumstances.  
 
 Dates Vary: Specific dates may differ depending on requirements, seasonal considerations, or other influencing elements, allowing for tailored arrangements.  

February 1, 2026

February 26, 2028

Tranquility Cottage

&

More Getaways LLC

"We Take You Places"

888-66-GETAWAYS

Get a Price Quote

Multi-line address
Birthday
Month
Day
Year
Select a destination

These are the Vacation We offer a variety of rentals, and each property is linked to a Listing ID (TG-****). Please select one to reference for your quote.

Vacation Type
How many people going
Budget Per person
Group Budgets
Accommodations
Schedule an appointment
March 2026
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
Week starting Sunday, March 15
Time zone: Coordinated Universal Time (UTC)Online meeting
Saturday, Mar 21
10:00 AM - 11:00 AM
11:00 AM - 12:00 PM
12:00 PM - 1:00 PM
1:00 PM - 2:00 PM
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
bottom of page
Tranquility Cottage & More Getaways, LLC BBB Business Review