top of page
< Back

Amara Cay Resort

TG-0019

Islamorada

United States

Amara Cay Resort — Islamorada, Florida Keys Summary A boutique, coastal‑chic oceanfront resort in Islamorada with hammocks, a private beach, a waterfront pool, and access to all sister‑property amenities across the Islamorada Resort Collection. Ideal for relaxed luxury, boating, water activities, and laid‑back Keys style Location • 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036 • Oceanfront, with views of Alligator Reef Lighthouse Nearest Airport • Miami International Airport (MIA) — ~1 hr 45 min • Key West International Airport (EYW) — ~1 hr 45 min Boutique, modern, coastal‑chic design: • Private beach with hammocks • Oceanfront pool + poolside bar • Access to 3 sister resorts, 12 restaurants, 55+ boat slips, and shared amenities Amenities (Dense List) On‑Site • Oceanfront pool • Private beach w/ hammocks • Tiki Bar • Fitness center • Complimentary activities (yoga, local-style fishing, water shuttles between sister resorts) Sister‑Property Access • Restaurants, pools, beaches, events, and marina access across the Islamorada Resort Collection Guest Services • Free shuttle within 3.7 miles • Complimentary guest laundry • Meeting/event spaces Room Types Standard Rooms & Suites • Private balconies or lanais • Ocean, pool, or garden views • Coastal‑chic décor • Flat‑screen TV, desk, safe Features Guests Highlight • “Brand‑new feel,” modern lobby, beautiful outdoor areas • Oceanfront rooms highly praised Guest Experience Snapshot • Tripadvisor rating: 4.2/5 (2,225 reviews) • Loved for: • Relaxed luxury • Friendly staff • Beautiful pool + beach • Water shuttle between properties • Clean, modern design • Noted trade‑offs: • Paid private parking Nearby Activities • History of Diving Museum (3 miles) • Anne’s Beach (8‑minute drive) • Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park (8‑minute drive) Perfect For • Couples seeking relaxed luxury • Families wanting beach + pool + activities • Guests who want multiple resort experiences in one stay • Boaters (55+ slips across sister properties)

Availability
The schedule for availability is subject to change based on various factors, ensuring flexibility to accommodate different needs and circumstances.  
 
 Dates Vary: Specific dates may differ depending on requirements, seasonal considerations, or other influencing elements, allowing for tailored arrangements.  

February 1, 2026

February 26, 2028

Tranquility Cottage

&

More Getaways LLC

"We Take You Places"

888-66-GETAWAYS

Get a Price Quote

Multi-line address
Birthday
Month
Day
Year
Select a destination

These are the Vacation We offer a variety of rentals, and each property is linked to a Listing ID (TG-****). Please select one to reference for your quote.

Vacation Type
How many people going
Budget Per person
Group Budgets
Accommodations
Schedule an appointment
March 2026
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
Week starting Sunday, March 1
Time zone: Coordinated Universal Time (UTC)Online meeting
Saturday, Mar 7
10:00 AM - 11:00 AM
11:00 AM - 12:00 PM
12:00 PM - 1:00 PM
1:00 PM - 2:00 PM
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
bottom of page
Tranquility Cottage & More Getaways, LLC BBB Business Review